Quote:
Originally Posted by GioforPM
Wasn't it Brodie who got torched by McDavid more often?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Machiavelli
Please explain this for me. At least to make me feel better about this trade.
|
I don't think that's accurate, but you should still feel good about the trade.
First of all, the difference between Gio/Dougie and Gio/Brodie is negligible in the grand scheme of things. Both pairs do what you want your top pairing to do. As disappointing as Brodie's play has been (since Dougie was acquired, really), when Brodie is on, Brodie can control the entire game. I never saw Dougie dominate in the way Brodie is capable. Dougie returned a much more significant package than Brodie. I'm okay with moving him in a deal that returns Hanifin and Lindholm. I wouldn't be okay if we just got one, but when for both I have no qualms.
Second, Hanifin is 21. He's had three full NHL seasons under his belt. His offense is there, and his defense is coming. Defenders take time - they have to be allowed to make mistakes. We all love to mention all the games Kylington has played in the AHL and how's he only the exact same age as Hanifin who's played nearly as many NHL contests. He's going to be fine.
Third, the Flames got a first line forward out of the deal as well. Someone who can play centre, who has excellent faceoff numbers, who plays 3v3, PK, who is 23 and cost controlled for his best years. Lindholm is likely to cost less than any free agent winger we could sign for the top six. My bold prediction: Lindholm outscores every free agent RW available July 1. Johnny and Monahan wrecked the league with a 32 year old Jiri Hudler. I am more than comfortable betting they can do more with 24-28 year old Elias Lindholm.
Lots to like, I'm excited to see how they work.