Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nelson
2017-18
Together at 5v5, Hamilton and Giordano have a CF% of 58.25%. Without Giordano at 5v5, Hamilton has a CF% of 53.33%. Without Hamilton at 5v5, Giordano has a CF% of 53.33%.
2014-15
Together at 5v5, Giordano and Brodie had a CF% of 49.00% (the Flames were awful). Without Giordano at 5v5, Brodie had a CF% of 39.18%. Without Brodie at 5v5, Giordano has a CF% of 43.00%.
|
In 17-18, Hamilton and Giordano were making each other better at controlling shot attempts and equally good at controlling shot attempts apart from one another. Giordano was not carrying Hamilton.
If you look at 16-17, Hamilton was way better without Giordano in 318 minutes at 5v5 (52.5 CF%) than Giordano was without Hamilton in 384 minutes at 5v5 (47.3%).
However, Giordano was carrying Brodie’s in 2014-15. In 2014-15, Giordano and Brodie played over 1000 minutes together at 5v5 and Brodie played over 550 minutes without Giordano at 5v5. Without Giordano, Brodie was absolutely horrible.
|
The very stats you tried to quote suggested that Brodie made Giordano better, just not by the same amount as Giordano made Brodie better.
To suggest Brodie was carried is pure revisionist's history.