[FireGilbert]

I had a bigger post typed out but it was repeating what others had said: McDavid is elite offensively but Crosby is the far better all around player.

Now McDavid is still young and could one day be as good as Crosby is now if he improves on face offs and two way play while cutting down on trying to go one on one. I can’t see this happening on the Oilers though where putting up points and getting big contacts seems to be preferred over winning.