Quote:
Originally Posted by btimbit
Are there any reasons for disliking a Peters hire or is it just that he hasn't won any cups? The more I read about him the more I'm starting to like him, and I'm starting to see a lot of Hurricanes fans on Reddit and HF come out to say we'd be getting a good coach.
Wondering where the hate is coming from other than a fear of him liking analytics and structure reminding people of Gulutzan.
Just curious, I'm not about to start praising this potential move until I learn more so just want to know where the hate is comingfrom
|
Sure, and are there any reasons for thinking he is a good hiring option?
Don’t introduce emotional terms like hate. Maybe try confusion. Or flabbergastedness, if that is a word
The Canes didn’t improve in terms of standings under his watch
It’s not cups. He has never made the playoffs
Again, it is not proof of success, it is failure and excuses and hope
Sutter for example has had tremendous success in his last two stops in very different circumstances
Forget the context and ask the simple version of the question
Scenario A - you have a guy you introduced in to two problem situations, he quickly made an immediate and positive impact and in one case even won the ultimate prize twice
Scenario B - you have a guy you introduce in to a problem situation. He doesn’t improve from the previous coach’s results, spends 4 years and doesn’t improve the results during that time. Doesn’t finish in the top half of the league or even make the playoffs.
How do you actually add in enough information to make B preferable to A?