Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post - R1 - Series Thread

3rd liner · 04-12-2018, 11:24 PM

Don't get me wrong- can't STAND Doughty and his whiny, fake-tough guy routine, but not sure if I agree with the severity of the punishment. Can't argue there was some head contact and it was an aggressive hit- worthy of some discipline. This is their star NHL defenseman with no suspension history. Just seems like DOPS twists the interpretation of the rules to support their decision. They admit the arm/shoulder was the first point of contact but interpret it wasn't the 'main point of contact'. How do you quantify that? Play happens so fast out there- if you go in to shoulder a guy from the side, hit the arm/shoulder first and the follow through catches the head on the way through that's a miscalculation, not dirty.
Carrier was massively running Doughty all game- no charging penalties dished out. He was running Gio in the last flames/knights game which is where he came onto my radar. For an 'energy' tough guy, Carrier sure can't seem to take what he dishes out. Another player that runs guys till the cows come home but you run him back he goes crying to the officials. 1 NHL fight this whole season.

04-12-2018, 11:24 PM	#65
3rd liner #1 Goaltender Join Date: Mar 2011 Exp:	Don't get me wrong- can't STAND Doughty and his whiny, fake-tough guy routine, but not sure if I agree with the severity of the punishment. Can't argue there was some head contact and it was an aggressive hit- worthy of some discipline. This is their star NHL defenseman with no suspension history. Just seems like DOPS twists the interpretation of the rules to support their decision. They admit the arm/shoulder was the first point of contact but interpret it wasn't the 'main point of contact'. How do you quantify that? Play happens so fast out there- if you go in to shoulder a guy from the side, hit the arm/shoulder first and the follow through catches the head on the way through that's a miscalculation, not dirty. Carrier was massively running Doughty all game- no charging penalties dished out. He was running Gio in the last flames/knights game which is where he came onto my radar. For an 'energy' tough guy, Carrier sure can't seem to take what he dishes out. Another player that runs guys till the cows come home but you run him back he goes crying to the officials. 1 NHL fight this whole season. Last edited by 3rd liner; 04-12-2018 at 11:30 PM.