[St. Pats]

Originally Posted by Macindoc

If we are insisting on trading a defenseman, I would agree that we should trade someone who is at their peak value. This would rule out Brodie and Hamonic, who had off years, and whose current trade value is much less than their future value to the team.

That leaves Hamilton, Gio and Stone. The latter isn't getting much of a return. But I wonder if after a near Norris-calibre season (would have been considered if the Flames made the playoffs), the time has come to trade Gio. His value will never be higher, and I think the team could use more vocal leadership (nothing against the guy, but he is quiet, and I think a young team that is emotionally fragile needs a bit more of a cheerleader for a captain). His play will likely regress over the next several years, until his contract becomes a bit of an anchor near the end. So if we could trade him now (maybe with a prospect) for two top nine wingers, we could help improve our team balance, shake up the leadership, and improve our long-term cap situation.

Be a bold move and one that would get a good return. It's from their position of strength. Gio is a top player but he isn't getting any younger. Now would be a good time to move him and dump Brouwer and just turn the team over leadership wise to Tkachuk.