Quote:
Originally Posted by Beninho
Hamilton is a much better player than Brodie, you trade Brodie before Hamilton every time. Brodie is by far the worst defensively of the Flames top 4 Dmen and his offensive contributions are not enough to mitigate his defensive lapses. Trade Brodie for a cost controlled effective winger. Doubt it happens tho
|
No not every time. If Brodie is going to return a reasonable top 6 winger and Hamilton is going to return an elite top line winger who is young you have to consider moving Dougie.
Brodie never sucked under Hartley and has only struggled under Gulutzan and I think it is largely due to playing on the left.
People that want Brodie gone have failed to answer the question of who is the second pair LHD as well. Gulutzan hates playing 2 same handed Dmen together so we have Kulak in the top 4 and our D looks pretty awful.