Quote:
Originally Posted by Fuzz
I disagree. From how I see it, Luke left Yoda, faced Vader in Empire, then trained for a year between the 2 movies (not with Yoda) then rescued Han, then returned to Yoda in this scene. If Luke had spent the year training with Yoda would he not asked these questions immediately, rather than a year in? He says "But I need your help. I've come back to complete the training." It only makes sense that this is in reference to the training Luke had in Empire. Otherwise I'd expect a different conversation that tells the audience that Luke has spent most of the past year with Yoda.
|
Perhaps. The canon doesn't seem to be clear on where Luke was between the 2 movies, but it is clear on the fact it was around a year and his jedi abilities where greatly increased during that time.
Whether he was training alone, with Yoda, or with force Ben isn't the crux of the debate anyway.
The initial post I responded to mentioned he was untaught just like Rey, but his rise did in fact have these gaps in time for him to develop which is the fundamental difference from untrained Rey.