Quote:
Originally Posted by cross16
I think he is good yes. Great? probably not and certainly not BB good but I also think that is an outlier as I consider him one of the best of all time in any sport. Most coaches don't win without their franchise QB and I also don't think any coach has been hampered by their GM as much as McCarthy. Thompson's refusal to do whatever is takes to improve his team and his complete avoidance of free agency I think has made McCarthy's job tougher.
I think the bottom line for me on McCarthy is you may be able to find someone better but it's probably just as easy to find someone worse. Don't think an upgrade is as easy as some of Packer fans do.
|
McCarthy to me is someone that got promoted one level too high. He should be an offensive coordinator. In terms of in game decisions (i.e. when to go for it on 4th down, when to challenge a play, clock and timeout management) he has been terrible for years. He has terrible situational awareness.