Don't think Gillies had a disappointing year. It was a bit up and down but the Flames and Treliving have talked about it being a good year for his development. Not easy to come back after surgery and a year off, let's not downplay that. I think his year is a bit unfairly criticized amongst the fan base because Rittich looks more developed. Rittich being more developed right now with his more extensive pro experience doesn't mean Gillies isn't on track in his own development. Rittich impressing does not mean Gillies disappointed.
Think it should be Gillies here because of his upside as a star goalie. I don't see any probable 1st liners or top 3 defencemen left on the list.
|