View Single Post
Old 04-24-2017, 04:50 PM   #1885
tkflames
First Line Centre
 
tkflames's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Exp:
Default

Funding models aside - what are peoples opinion on the trade-off between the two projects? Obviously the funding model is a critical component, but this is also the most negotiable component. For me the two projects break down as follows:

Victoria Park
Benefits:
1. In conjunction with the Green line, access to this location from throughout the city is far better than the any alternative proposed.

2. Easiest path (likely fastest) to a new arena. Based on the presentation today and the size of area allocated, this would be a middle of road entertainment center.

3. Allows the city to develop to completion in the East before moving west.

Drawback
1. Fit for purpose design with a bit of perks to get excited about if Stampede Trail becomes a reality. Based on both size and application, this arena lacks the flare factor.

2. Limited traffic at the arena/event center outside of events (much like the saddle dome). Outside of a few extra concerts per year, I don't think there will be regular traffic at this facility. I suspect this will affect the viability of the stampede trail businesses.

Calgary Next:

Benefits
1. Despite what this thread has deteriorated the project too; in terms of facilities and amenities, this is a well thought out project attempting to capture a number of different sporting and entertainment facilities and applications. The actual idea behind Calgary Next as a facility is something that would be easy to get excited about.

2. Consistent traffic through the facility will also improve the viability of a surrounding entertainment district and central gathering place.

Drawbacks
1. In addition to the environmental clean-up, currently the only planned public transportation station is Sunalta (going east-west only). The additional road traffic modifications required around Bow Trail and Crowchild trail is a massive undertaking.

2. There is a risk that a renewed financial focus on West Village will leave two partially completed projects 20 years down the road.


Does this more or less capture it for most, or are there key positives and drawbacks that I am missing on both projects? Am I misleading in my analysis?
__________________
Go Flames Go
tkflames is offline  
The Following 3 Users Say Thank You to tkflames For This Useful Post: