Quote:
Originally Posted by Fan in Exile
Anyone else find some irony in the fact that while Treliving is generally lauded on this board and Chiarelli is the subject of scorn and ridicule on the Edmonton is no good thread, that aside from undeservedly picking up McDavid, the Oilers have picked up Talbot, Larsson and Lucic (I know he's a left-winger but still and there's Maroon as well), who are basically the ideal players to fill the holes we have in our line-up.
I don't bring this up with admiration, just suggesting that maybe we've over-rated Treliving and under-rated Chiarelli who has built more of a Burke-style truculent team that's tough to play against in two years than Treliving has accomplished with his acquisitions.
|
It was rumoured that Tre was in on both Talbot and Jones and in the sames offseason picked up Hamilton. Also Lucic at that money and Term.... No thanks! And the oilers give up Hall for Larson, do you recommend we give up Gaudreau for a top 4 D?
Chia also gave a up a 1st rounder ++ for Reinhardt. Ouch.
Apples and oranges man, apples and oranges.