Quote:
Originally Posted by GGG
I'm complaining the other way.
We are deprived of Montreal vs Toronto because the system isn't archaic enough. There should not be wildcard teams if 4 teams from the division make the playoffs regardless of totals. The 5th place team crossing over makes sense but swapping two fourth place teams giving up rivalries isn't good for entertainment.
I think that the idea that the playoffs should be a properly seeded tournament pitting best vs worst each round is flawed. The idea should be to have the most entertaining season and playoffs as possible. This means emphasizing rivalries over idealized points
|
You nailed it on the wildcard. Having the wildcard cross over when there are 4 teams from each division in the playoffs is just dumb.
I'm okay with rivalry seeding, or with 1-8 conference seeding, but this hybrid system doesn't make much sense for me.
If you are going to do rivalry seeding then commit to it all the way.