Hate it. Slows down the game, kills momentum, takes attention away from the play. It is also part of the NFL-ization of hockey (coupled, for example, with referees announcing what the penalty is for Americans and people who don't know what the hand signals mean).
Speaking more philosophically, it takes away from the ambiguities and contingencies of hockey that make it interesting (things like, was that player really offside? Was Hull's famous Stanley-Cup-winning goal with his skate in the crease? Etc.). Arguing about whether or not a call was correct, especially after several beers, is an integral part of sports fandom.
Hey while we're at it let's make a coach's challenge optional for every penalty. That will make the game more fair!
__________________
"Two-liner!"
-Terry
|