I get what you're saying, Matty, and I agree that there is a bit of an inherent benefit there (getting that tryout period at the NHL level, simply because there are no other options), however, in the end, I don't think it matters. Every avenue has its pros and cons.
For example, take Shinkaruk. It could be argued that Tkachuk got an unfair opportunity. However, SHinkaruk has the opportunity to work on his game in the AHL (where it is a bit easier to stand out and where he'll get more icetime), and he has the entire year as his window for a call-up.
At some point there will be injuries on the big club. That opens up an opportunity for someone to get full minutes. And the person called up is probably some who is currently playing really well and has lots of confidence. SO it becomes a perfect opportunity (as opposed to the 9 games, which are huge pressure).
Long story short, every path leads to the same place - it's up to the player to take advantage of their opportunities when they come along.
|