Quote:
Originally Posted by GullFoss
Tkachuk has all the phsyical and mental tools to play at the NHL levels - arguably he's more physically able than Monahan, Johnny or Bennett were in each of their first years in the league.
So what's the issue? I think the story is nuanced - its because Tkachuk isn't physically mature enought to play HIS game at the NHL level at a top-6 level. Simply put, its hard being an 18-y/o power forward against 24+ year old players.
But, he's not going to get stronger faster playing in Junior vs. the AHL vs. the NHL. He's not going to get any stronger getting 10 minutes a night vs. 20 minutes a night.
So what's the answer...I think the answer is the NHL for two reasons. First, you get access to better coaches - specifically diet and conditioning. That should help him progress faster where he needs to. Second, he makes the team better when he's in a bottom-6 role here. So, i believe Tkachuk staying up here is better for the team and better for his development.
|
I agree with your analysis of being an 18 year old power forward trying to compete with 24 years old PFs but I say send him down.
An extra year in junior will allow him to grow and get stronger. With the type of game he plays, some 24 year old may decide to take him on and put a permanent blow to his development.