Tkachuk has all the phsyical and mental tools to play at the NHL levels - arguably he's more physically able than Monahan, Johnny or Bennett were in each of their first years in the league.
So what's the issue? I think the story is nuanced - its because Tkachuk isn't physically mature enought to play HIS game at the NHL level at a top-6 level. Simply put, its hard being an 18-y/o power forward against 24+ year old players.
But, he's not going to get stronger faster playing in Junior vs. the AHL vs. the NHL. He's not going to get any stronger getting 10 minutes a night vs. 20 minutes a night.
So what's the answer...I think the answer is the NHL for two reasons. First, you get access to better coaches - specifically diet and conditioning. That should help him progress faster where he needs to. Second, he makes the team better when he's in a bottom-6 role here. So, i believe Tkachuk staying up here is better for the team and better for his development.
|