No that's a good post. If anything I was probably a bit too hard on both Waters and Gilmour in my post.
My only real retort would be regarding the album by committee comment. I don't have a source, but I recall reading about how Gilmour had tremendous difficulties writing for Lapse and DB and had to bring in a ton of help to get the albums done. I have a couple of books on PF may have been on one. Or it was online. I'll try and find it.
|