Quote:
Originally Posted by FireGilbert
For some reason I spent a lot of time thinking about this. Both were huge HRs in elimination games however I give the edge to EE because his was an extra innings walk off. In the case of JB, the Rangers still had two innings to tie the game (or if he didn't hit the HR the Jays still had two innings to take the lead).
I have also debated Sprague vs Alomar as both HRs were 9th inning comebacks against top closers and were major reasons for the 92 World Series win. In this case I give the edge to Sprague since it gave the Jays the lead, while the Alomar one just tied the game.
In any case I am sure we can all agree on:
-Carter: Biggest HR in Jays history
-Sprague: Biggest pinch hit HR in Jays history
-Alomar: Biggest HR in Jays ALCS history
-JB: Biggest HR in Jays ALDS history
-EE: Biggest HR in Wild Card hisory
|
-Winfield: Biggest double, arguably the biggest hit in Jays history as well in the 11th of the clincher in '92.