It is obviously difficult to compare players from different eras. More importantly, the selection largely depends on whether one wants to assemble team for an all-star game or a team that would dominate regular NHL season and play-offs (where you'd need some PK, faceoffs, size, grit, etc.)
If latter is the case, here's my squad with 5 extra forwards and 2 extra dmen.
Jarome Iginla - Joe Nieuwendyk - Theoren Fleury
Gary Roberts - Doug Gilmour - Lanny McDonald
Hakan Loob - Joel Otto - Colin Patterson
Ville Nieminnen - Stephane Yelle - Tim Hunter
+
Johnny Gaudreau (subst. for Theo/Lanny)
Craig Conroy (subst. for center position)
Sergei Makarov (subst. for Loob/Lanny)
Kent Nilsson (subst. for Roberts/Loob)
Chris Simon (subst. for Hunter/Nieminnen)
Al MacInnis - Gary Suter
Mark Giordano - Robyn Regehr
Paul Reinhart - Frank Musil
+
Rob Ramage (subst. for Suter/Regehr/Musil)
T.J.Brodie (subst. for MacInnis/Reinhart/Gio)
Kipper
Vernon
|