Interesting question and depends on one's own definition of star. It is obviously very subjective.
Johnny is a star by any measure IMO. Other than winning at the pro level I suppose. To me, a star makes you come out of your seat and is a player that opposing fans will grudgingly admit they admire and fear. Maybe the Flames only have one right now. I don't believe there are too many true stars in the NHL. A star has the potential to be in the HHOF one day.
I definitely say no to Monahan at this point. Top 15 at your position might make you a great player but not a star.
|