Quote:
Originally Posted by GioforPM
I'd be a bit wary of stats when looking at backup who could possibly turn into number ones, because of the lower sample size and possible lower quality of opposition. Some backups with lesser stats have turned into quality starters and some who looked great and had nice stats did not.
|
This is also slightly true for goalies that are starters, but haven't carried a heavy workload. Examples of this would be Reimer and Andersen.
In 6 full seasons in the NHL, Reimer has never played more than 37 games. Since he's somewhat of a veteran goaltender overall, I think we'd be fairly sure what we're getting with him. Unlike former LA, NY, and Boston goalies, Reimer has played behind bad defenses.
In 3 full seasons, Andersen has played over 50 games once. However, this was his worst season statistically. He has also played behind a strong defense. He's also younger with more possible upside.
We should evaluate all goaltenders on the same criteria, rather than just evaluating backups on their team quality and historic starts.