Quote:
Originally Posted by FlamesAddiction
I think that would be really dark, even for this show.
I have heard some arguments that because they never showed Glenn during the "eeny, meeny, miney, moe", that it makes sense it was him. I wasn't paying that much attention myself, but I don't recall them showing Carl either for that matter.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by OutOfTheCube
Not a chance -- mostly because Rick isn't going to just sit there and watch someone beat his son to death. He'd go ballistic/crazy and get himself killed as well. Then... show over, pretty much.
|
Both very good points. It was just a feeling I got when I rewatched it and like Hockeyguy said, it could very well be the product over-analysis.
I mean, after watching it the first time I said 'okay, so its not Rick or Carl' and I still feel that it is quite certainly not Rick, but Carl? I dont know. I have firmly shifted to the fence on that one.
It would be dark, it would seriously affect the storyline next season and it would be a fairly violent shift in tone for the show as a whole.
But I'm not yet ready to go back to the concrete statement that it was not Carl without some compelling evidence.