The Hobey Baker Finalist voting is not very transparent. So it is tough to say. Below is a listing of 2006 and 2007 winners and finalists.
2006
Winner: Matt Carle, D, Denver
Chris Collins, F, Boston College*
Brian Elliott, G, Wisconsin*
Andy Greene, D, Miami
Greg Moore, F, Maine
Scott Parse, F, Nebraska-Omaha
Ryan Potulny, F, Minnesota
Marty Sertich, F, Colorado College
Brett Sterling, F, Colorado College
T.J. Trevelyan, F, St. Lawrence
2007
Winner: Ryan Duncan, F, North Dakota
David Brown, G, Notre Dame*
Eric Ehn, F, Air Force*
Drew Bagnall, D, St. Lawrence
John Curry, G, Boston University
Nathan Davis, F, Miami
Bobby Goepfert, G, St. Cloud State
T.J. Hensick, F, Michigan
David Jones, F, Dartmouth
Scott Parse, F, Nebraska-Omaha
Read more:
http://www.uscho.com/faq/hobey/#ixzz430PBSHiA
Interesting that Johnathan Toews also wasn't a top 10 finalist.
http://www.hockeydb.com/ihdb/stats/p....php?pid=93829
Toews had good stats as well while at University of North Dakota. Not sure how the NCAA comes to these listings.