Quote:
Originally Posted by Flames Draft Watcher
Are they? Brodie's amazing but there's other amazing d-men in the league too. Saying he's top 10 easily may be a matter of underrating some of the other guys.
Doughty
Hedman
Keith
Josi
Karlsson
Burns
Weber
Subban
Ekman-Larsson
Giordano
Klingberg
Letang
Brodie
Barrie
Suter
Byfuglien
McDonagh
Ekblad
Pietrangelo
Seabrook
Which of those are the top 10 in the league? It's not so simple a list to make IMO. I think Brodie is easily in the conversation. Is he easily in the top 10? It's an interesting discussion that is very relevant to this thread. You believe he is, convince us!  |
I would take Brodie over all the bolded. I obviously watch the Flames more than anyone else so there's inherent bias there. Suter is borderline, and given age, I would have Brodie.