Quote:
Originally Posted by pylon
You don't know how important making that volley ball team is to the other girl either. She could have practiced and trained for an entire year to make the team, and be devastated not to, while the other girl could be kind of disinterested and was simply put on the team because she's taller than all the other girls, and would make a good blocker at the net.
|
Changed your post to highlight the important failing in your example.
This situation occurs all the time in both male and female sports on every single level. It is not unique to transgender inclusion. Your argument is against the inclusion of anyone with a genetic advantage. In addition, the "genetic advantage" of a transgender female is not automatic or guaranteed.
P.S. should another thread be created? This has moved pretty far away from the point of the thread and into transgendered sports participation.