Quote:
Originally Posted by Enoch Root
I think most Edmontonians think that the arena development is/will spark downtown growth.
Your Columbus argument is the same one usually made: no proof that the growth is from the arena. No proof because it is difficult to prove. The bottom line though is that the area is growing successfully.
You would be hard pressed to find a Winnipegger that argued that the arena didn't revitalize the downtown area.
|
As you mention. It's anecdotal. It's your experience which is great bit substitution is a real thing that can be quantified. It happens in cities with any sort of entertainment. I'm glad you can spend more on vacations but most are limited by time off and other factors. Many people will choose to spend the money in town. Maybe more nights out at restaurants, drinking, movies, etc.
Business will also have a ton of more money for their marketing budgets. It's not like they will say well no hockey. I guess we don't market anymore.
And you are somewhat right. While there is no evidence arenas increase economic growth, all the studies in the world probably couldn't provide conclusive enough evidence to convince the pro-growthers that it doesn't help. But, I'm not willing to allow my city to write a blank cheque over anecdotal evidence of some new margaritavilles and normal growth rates.
People won't move to a city because of a new arena. They won't spend more money because of a new arena.