Quote:
Originally Posted by ScorchyScorch
In the forest scene, when Kylo tried to pull the lightsaber from the snow and it instead flew past him, I thought (well the fanboy in me) it was going to land in the hand of Luke, who would show up to save the day and confront his traitor padawan. That would've IMO made for a badass appearance. But then I remembered he would've been in recluse for a reason and leaving maps only to show up in the middle of a battle wouldn't make sense. But that would've made for a great reveal.
The actual one was way more open ended and makes for a lot of intrigue. But if I had written the scene I would've had Rey searching for a couple days, and eventually becoming exhausted and nearly giving up, before Luke having stalked her the entire time decides to show up just as nightfall comes about, clearly having lost some of his humanity, and acting very hostile at first (maybe even force-pulls her to him and starts to choke her) until she shows him the lightsaber in desperation. Then have him collapse, and ask all shocked sounding "who are you?.." and then cut to the credits. That's kind of how I imagined it would go down. Oh well!
|
Well done! That thing with the lightsabre would have indeed been badass. I actually had a similar idea when they were at the planet where Maz was and Rey was running through the forest. She would stumble across his temple somehow. Like a "he's been here the whole time!" thing, and the map was just to throw everyone off.
I like your version, that would have been great.