Quote:
Originally Posted by Lurch
I think it comes down to the perceived value of the position. Safety is probably considered the least important position on defense in the NFL. Not sure if it is deserved, but certainly the perception is there. Personally, I think Polamalu is only maybe the #1 safety - Ed Reed certainly is at a similar level though a different type, and Roy Williams in Dallas is probably at least as good. Also, Sean Taylor in Washington is a wrecking ball, but has rocks for brains so probably will squander his superior physical talent.
As for best defensive players in the league overall, I personally think pass rushing tackles such as Henderson (Jax) bring the most value. (Shaun Rogers as well). The difference between a stud tackle and an average one is more of a defense maker than anywhere else, IMO. Pressure of the middle from a big body kills the running game, and gives QB's fits unlike guys like Freeney who can be gameplanned around much easier.
|
I would agree that it is true for an average safety versus average guys at other positions. But with Polamalu and Reed they are able to change the game so much with their coverage, INTs, sacks, tackling that I think they are able to impact the game more than almost any other defensive player in the league. Because of how special they are I would take eithe r over a guy like Rogers (and I am a huge lions fan and love Rogers) because of their versatility.