[quote=Superflyer;552176][quote=Igottago;552124]
Can you imagine any of the following people on this show? Bob Dylan, Neil Young, Kurt Cobain, Thom Yorke? They all would've lost.
Quote:
The thing with this is when you look at Bob Dylan and Neil Young, no offence to them, but they are old school. Totally diffrent kind of rock then what is going on on this show. As for Kurt and Thom well how can you say that they would not have won when so many of there songs are covered on the show. Sure they did not have the wild stage presence that Supernova seems to be looking for but once again, diffrent type of people and diffrent type of rock.
|
Dylan, Young, and Yorke got where they are because of their song writing, not because they were charismatic front men.
Cobain may well have done well on this show. Can't picture him actually being on it though.