Calgarypuck Forums - The Unofficial Calgary Flames Fan Community - View Single Post

mile · 09-26-2015, 02:03 AM

Best Winners:
Will, Dan, Derrick

Good Winners:
Hayden, Jun, Maggie

Decent Winners:
Andy, Boogie, Lisa, Drew, Steve, Ian

Worst Winners:
Adam, Jordan, Dick, Rachel

I would say Steve is a deserving winner, but still probably in the bottom half.

I don't remember anything Drew did in his season other than cutting his girlfriend, who I believe was the one running the game at the time - so it's hard to compare him to Steve.

Steve is very similar to Ian, but I would put Ian below him because when Steve cut Vanessa, he made the move Ian should have made by cutting Dan at final 3 - Ian won due to a bitter jury.

Who is definitely worse than Steve?
Adam was not memorable at all, but my impression was that he was a weak winner.

I actually like Dick, but he definitely only won because of America's player.

Jordan's strategic game was non-existent.

Rachel won with a lot of help from production. Conveniently bringing the duos twist back at final 6, and then having the subsequent veto competition be the exact same game as the first HOH she won earlier in the season.

I pretty much agree with what Oling_Roachinen said. Boogie is a decent winner but Will played a lot of his game.

09-26-2015, 02:03 AM	#216
mile Franchise Player Join Date: Mar 2014 Exp:	Best Winners: Will, Dan, Derrick Good Winners: Hayden, Jun, Maggie Decent Winners: Andy, Boogie, Lisa, Drew, Steve, Ian Worst Winners: Adam, Jordan, Dick, Rachel I would say Steve is a deserving winner, but still probably in the bottom half. I don't remember anything Drew did in his season other than cutting his girlfriend, who I believe was the one running the game at the time - so it's hard to compare him to Steve. Steve is very similar to Ian, but I would put Ian below him because when Steve cut Vanessa, he made the move Ian should have made by cutting Dan at final 3 - Ian won due to a bitter jury. Who is definitely worse than Steve? Adam was not memorable at all, but my impression was that he was a weak winner. I actually like Dick, but he definitely only won because of America's player. Jordan's strategic game was non-existent. Rachel won with a lot of help from production. Conveniently bringing the duos twist back at final 6, and then having the subsequent veto competition be the exact same game as the first HOH she won earlier in the season. I pretty much agree with what Oling_Roachinen said. Boogie is a decent winner but Will played a lot of his game.