Quote:
Originally Posted by MisterJoji
You don't think Giordano deserves to be in the top 10? You don't think his good offense/elite defense is more valuable than Subban and Karlsson's elite offense/average defense? You don't think he's a better defenseman than Roman fricking Josi?
|
He is top 10. I love Gio but guys like Karlsson and Subban take over a game, sure they make defensive gaffes here and there but thats only cuz they're trying to create offense all the time.
I love Gio but I wouldn't be worried one bit if he was replaced with Subban or Karlssob on the Flames.
Roman Josi is a very under-rated dman. Last year he was arguably better then his teammate who have you in the upper echelon.
It's hard to quantify who's better when all these guys are top players. Guys like McDonagh/Hedman/Pietrangelo are all amazing players.
Thats the elite NHl Dmen group:
Doughty/Weber/Keith/Suter/Karlsson/Subban/McDonagh/Pietrangelo/Josi/Gio/Hedman/OEL in no order