I put a lot of thought into my list this year. Deciding what my definition of a prospect is. For me Shore and Nakladal are prospects but that's neither here nor there. I vowed not to get swayed too much by draft position or a good development camp. I looked at what weight I give to factors like upside, NHL readiness, year-to-year progression (most important), character, team needs etc. And I think I made a good list. Better than all of yours I'm sure
However in the case of Sieloff I have violated the list's integrity. I really want him to succeed. I want a player of his best-case-scenario on the team.I fear he isn't going to get there though and this is the last time he is truly considered a possible NHLer. I think the evidence suggests the combination of injuries, lack of development time and just not quite enough skill mean he is going to fall short
Voted for him a couple of times now though. I hope he has that great year and is on the team next year or at least very much in the mix.