Quote:
Originally Posted by Timbo
Updated Again
In favour of GA reveal
1. Oling
Not in favour of the GA revealing at this time
1. GGG
2. Timbo
3. Peanut
4. mrkajz
Leave it up to the GA to decide
1. Starseed
2. Puxlut
3. Diss
Undecided
1.HG15
In during the timeline of conversation but never gave opinion.
1. Bizarro
2. Diss
3. Squiggs
Has not choosen at this time
1. Party Elephant
|
I would say I'm marginally opposed to the GA revealing at this time. If they reveal and we get a counterclaim, we have essentially a 50/50 shot at killing the agent. If there is an active turned alive (which I think we need to assume) they have a lower cost of making a counter claim than one of the scum, as they can't communicate or get the spore back to send it. We're getting close to the point where the agent can be a big help to the town in getting the numbers down (ie, killing Seb may have saved the game already).
I can see oling's point about having another "confirmed" townie. As we get closer to the endgame I think the upside to having the GA reveal gets greater, as it reduces the places the scum has to hide. I don't think we're at lynch or lose yet, so I think it makes sense for the agent to hide for another day or maybe two at the most.
Ultimately though, if the agent feels they have information that could help the town figure out who to lynch now then I would trust their judgement. I guess I probably should go in the "agent decides" category on Timbo's list, but with a "leaning to not reveal" caveat.