Phaneuf never had great IQ and has now lost his confidence, that combination has left him borderline useless. I could see a change in scenery helping but I don't think he'll ever be better than an average #4 d-man with some significant downside risk (ie. his decision-making). Add in his contract and he has very little trade value. Given the state of the rest of their roster D-men and prospects, they're probably better off keeping him and seeing if Babcock can work with him.
|