View Single Post
Old 05-21-2015, 04:07 PM   #51
Oling_Roachinen
Franchise Player
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Exp:
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Puxlut View Post
But the first one to admit it gets a free pass. If the Captain says it's him and he passed it to passenger A and we kill Passenger A, that doesn't help us. And then we aren't going to target the Captain because we thing he was just the first schmuck to get the spore.
Well in that scenario, either the Scum actually does send it to Passenger A in which case:

Tomorrow, Passenger A remains a passenger and tells us that he was sent the spore. We, unfortunately, should still kill and we remove the spore for a night. That's a decent outcome for us. We might trust Scum a bit more, but we know there's a possibility he was lying.

Or

Tomorrow, Passenger A turns. We still kill him and we remove the spore for a night. That's a decent outcome for us.

Or the Scum doesn't send the spore to Passenger A, in which case:

Tomorrow, Passenger A remains a passenger and tells us that he was not sent a spore. We, unfortunately, should still probably kill him if no one else comes forward. But once he reveals passenger we know that the Scum lied to us. That would be a great outcome for us.

Or, Passenger A remains a passenger and the real target of the spore, if not turned, comes forward as well and says he was actually sent the spore and now we have Passenger A and "Real Target" going up against the lying Scum. Another great outcome for us.
Oling_Roachinen is offline   Reply With Quote