Quote:
Originally Posted by Cali Flames Fan
First of all, what is the criteria? It seems to be somewhat subjective other than qualifying to be a rookie, no? It's actually "most proficient", which leaves a ton of room for interpretation as proficient means "competent or skilled at doing something".
http://www.nhl.com/ice/page.htm?id=24931
Secondly, I don't think the style in which you play has any bearing on the assessment for the award, nor do I think it should. |
How can you say age may be subjective yet entertainment impact not? It's an entertainment business first and foremost and while Ekblad had a fine season he never got anyone out of their seat like Johnny did at times. I don't have an issue with Ekblad winning the award but I would vote him 2nd to Gadreau who lead the league in rookie scoring, played a big role of getting his team into the playoffs (a team I may add that was predicted to finish behind the Panthers who missed the playoffs), and he provided more flash/entertainment.