Quote:
Originally Posted by #-3
System doesn't make that much sense to me, looks like you are trying to asses long term asset value, ignoring anything other than the snap shoot of how/where the player is playing at this point and time. There are allot of other things that go into it.
Your saying Crosby is worth a teams next 6 first round picks? Even for Sid seems like a stretch, already in his late 20's
Gio at a 1st x 3 doesn't seem so far off, but still high considering his age. But in terms of long term value to a building franchise you have to think Brodie, Monahan, and Gaudreau hold more asset value than Gio.
Also are you saying you would trade Wotherspoon or Klimchuk for any second round pick right now, because you are saying that a late 2nd is worth more than either of them.
Do you really think you could get a high second or even late first for Jooris, Granlund or Ramo, because that is where you have them ranks, and I am here to tell you your out to lunch.
|
Brodie monahan and gaudreau hold significantly more value combined being 12200 vs gio at 5500
Wotherspoon and klimchuk came from weaker draft classes therefore there current ranking is that of a mid 2nd rounder this year.
I bet if Calgary had an offer at the deadline for a mid/late 2nd for jorris or ramo at the deadline it was declined as they do hold that value at this time.
I'm not saying that this is the end all be all chart, all that was intended was some good Heathly discussion regarding the current state of the franchise. Sorry for trying to bring that to the boards.