[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by polak

I don't know. To me, when it comes to MURDER, "justice" is quite a valid reason to keep someone locked up for the rest of their lives. He 100%, without doubt killed somebody on purpose and quite brutally and now there is a chance he will be free. That is not okay in my books regardless of sanity.

Plus, he's living in a group home and has to be heavily medicated for the rest of his life. It's not like society is missing out on much.

But then again, in situations like this, where there is zero doubt of who comitted the murder and why, I'm A-OK with the death penalty, so I'm biased. I just don't see how he deserves to be free in any way.

If I was the family of his victim I'd be devastated. How has justice been served? Their son/sibling/boyfriend/husband is gone, by virtue of public decapitation, and this guy gets to have any semblence of freedom? The system failed.

Actually your first post about seems to point to you thinking he should be killed or at the very least locked up forever.

Originally Posted by polak

Umm the entire time I was arguing that he should be kept under supervision for longer. Not that he should be held locked up forever. Never once did I say that.

I think he should be supervised for longer. That's all. It's only been 7 years.

It's not based on punishment, it's based on risk and apperance. Apperance to appease the public and the victims.