[undercoverbrother]

Originally Posted by polak

Just cause you choose to not answer them doesn't make it invalid.

It's not just a silly "what if" question. If he killed 25 people instead of 1, would we be letting him off unsupervised? Nothing has changed in terms of Li's stability or disease. He had one episode but this time, instead of killing one person, he killed 25.

If the answer to that question is not a resounding "Yes. I would still agree with the doctors and support him being allowed to go into the city unsupervised" then there is an inherent flaw in your logic. That would mean that you are basing your opinion on the outcome and severity of his "one-off" episode and not his current mental state, which then puts your whole opinion under fire as your interpretation on how "severe" that episode was, is probably far different than the opinion of the victims family and the people on that bus.

Next time answer properly before dismissing a question.

Says the guy that listed a "business degree" as his ability to comment on the mental state of an individual he has never met.........