Personally, I feel fielding defence is overrated if the person can't bat. I really wanted Melky back because of his great average. Saunders' bat is pretty decent, so he's just an okay replacement for Melky, but I don't think his defensive effectiveness will make up for Melky either. Sometimes you simply can't replace a great bat. Plus his injury proneness is one of the things that'll bite us in the butt again. I don't hold out much hope for this trade.
