I wasn't saying I thought it was defence though. Knowing that HG15's reveal was a hoax, it's not defence because you caught Starseed in a lie. Looking at what they were saying, I would think this is more where they picked up on the defence thing though:
http://forum.calgarypuck.com/showpos...postcount=4681
This was prior to Starseed saying the reveal was a hoax. You voted for him almost immediately once HG15 was named and you said that you were backed up by HG and Timbo. I think this is the "Us vs Them" that Pux was referring to in the quote above.
I mean for Starseed's mafia theory to work, it has to be you, HG15 and Timbo all together. All 3 of you have to have the same story for it to fly. We know that can't be true because that would leave me and Diss and the only town and at 3-2, we would have already lost. Starseed would have been lynched, that group would pick off Pux and Mazrim would announce the loss because the two remaining couldn't out vote you. Even with my power, couldn't win that vote.
They did keep pushing the you and HG15 though even after the hoax thing. That part, like everything after it, is what makes no sense. They made up something to connect you, had it proven wrong, kept pushing it.