Quote:
Originally Posted by Drury18
Starseed's final acts confuse the hell out of me though.
Trying to read through, it looks like when you defended HG15 right away after Starseed's "reveal" and then when HG15 was wiling to vote for you, they (Pux and Starseed) got suspicious.
|
I disagree with this. Here's the posts:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen
Haha, well this is interesting.
Unvote
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen
So if Starseed is town:
We vote out Hockeyguy15, we're (likely) down to 1 mafia member with Starseed, Puxlut and I would say Drury as confirmed townies. That's a great position to be in.
We vote out Starseed, it hurts but we get Hockeyguy15 tomorrow for sure. Still a shot to win.
If Starseed is mafia:
We vote out Hockeyguy15, we don't know if Starseed has an Eternal power or if they are real or anything. They get 3 votes, probably kill Diss and we lose tomorrow on a 3-3 tie.
We vote out Starseed, we win game after killing Puxlut tomorrow.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by starseed
I felt that he was the critical piece. I ignored Drury because I figured that I would be able to accept a loss due to him being mafia, as it would be OP for him to be mafia and have the ability to prevent the first mafia lynch.
HG backed up Oling's claim for his role. I still don't understand why he was left alive over Rathji if he were town.
I was going to avoid directly accusing Oling today, but I guess I have to for this to make sense. His alignment would prove to me that Oling was one way or the other. If HG was town, then Oling was town and mafia was Dissent/Timbo. If he was mafia, then his partner is probably Oling because he backed up Oling's claims when he could have asked for Pux's power at the time.
He could have got her mason power, which would prove her to be town, or her death faction investigation, which would prove her to be town as that is ridiculous for the mafia to have, or it her third power was the magikoopa hammer, which would still indicate that she was working with one other partner.
Also, I was meaning that I wanted to know if your doctor power message had bolded or coloured words in it. Not the one from the Eternals/Guardians.
|
I did not defend Hockeguy15, I presented all the possible scenarios (not factoring in the cult powers I guess) and then Starseed comes out with the logic that I am hockeyguy15's partner because he proved my claim. Timbo proved my claim too. My investigation powers are not up for debate. when Starseed accused me of being mafia, of course I went against him. Especially as he had 3 votes and enough to force a tie, and it would be terrible to have a 3-3 tie on Day 10...
