Quote:
Originally Posted by Hockeyguy15
We have two options. One is wait for starseed to explain himself, and then make a decision after we hear from him. The risk with that is he could be mafia with a kill, but he could also be town with a kill. The other option is lynch him before he can use the kill (although formulate tried to use his kill after he was lynched, so who knows).
I'm kind of leaning towards the wait and see, just because I'm not sure what to do. I would hate to quick lynch if he is town, but if he is scum and we give him time to use his kill I will also be kicking myself.
|
If he's town and he has a day kill, it's extremely obviously what needed to be done. The fact he didn't already do it makes me believe that isn't the case. He should have shot Puxlut, proved he was town and then we could follow his lead as the only 100% confirmed townie and at least know that it wouldn't be mafia leading us. The fact that Starseed has mentioned several times about proving the MOT leaves me no doubt he would have considered that plan.
So in my opinion, he can't be town with a day kill. He could be town with a night kill, but I don't think I could give him the benefit of the doubt based on all my reasons thinking he is mafia even before this incident.
If he's mafia with a day kill, it might not be a big deal. He kills one of us, we still lynch him by a vote of 4-3 and enter tomorrow 3-1 against Puxlut. Unless there's a double night kill and it's 2-1 and with Starseed dead they can't get the extra vote. (EXCEPT OOPS, just thinking this through it was Aeneas that confirmed Starseed and Puxlut have to target the person together for vote, that could obviously be a lie and only 1 of them actually has that power...might be why Starseed was okay dieing over Puxlut. Uggh.)
It's the extra vote that would cost us the game. If he comes in and votes for Timbo with Puxlut we lose (1 from their power, 1 from the Eternals, and their 2 votes is a lynch). The day ends 4-2, night kill brings us 3-2, and they tie the vote 3-3 tomorrow for the win.