[Flash Walken]

Hack Journalism at it's finest.

June 2013:

The Oilers aren’t going to throw away a player like Smid – despite his warts moving the puck, he has a great deal of value as a defenceman. He’s big, tough, plays an honest physical game and defends rather well. He has at times been quite good in a top-four role – notably towards the end of 2011-12 when he and Jeff Petry held their own as a top pairing for a significant stretch.

But the Oilers didn’t throw away Eric Brewer, either. They traded him and some spare pieces to St. Louis in exchange for Chris Pronger when that elite defenceman became available. It was, without question, the strongest move of Kevin Lowe’s managerial career, and one that worked out rather well for the Oilers.

If Edmonton finds themselves in a situation where they can add a legitimate top-pairing guy, Smid makes a lot of sense as a potential trade candidate – because he’s a good defenceman on a value contract in the prime of his career whose skillset isn’t a perfect marriage to the espoused philosophy of the new general manager.

EXPECTATION

None of this means that the Oilers are on the verge of trading Ladislav Smid, or even that Smid won’t spend the rest of his contract in Edmonton. He is a good player on a good contract; generally those are the kind of pieces a team likes to keep around. Additionally, it would make no sense to trade him except in a very specific scenario where the Oilers had the opportunity to trade a package built around Smid for a superior defenceman; they don’t have the defensive depth to move Smid out without replacing him at the same time or very, very shortly thereafter.

All it means is that Smid’s name should be written in pencil, rather than pen, on long-term projections.

April 2013:

MAKE NO MISTAKE: THIS IS A HUGE COUP FOR THE #OILERS. SMID WAS THE ONLY PROVEN TOP-4 ‘D’ UNDER THE AGE OF 32 ON THE UFA MARKET THIS SUMMER.

— JONATHAN WILLIS (@JONATHANWILLIS) APRIL 1, 2013

SMID WAS GOING TO GET PAID. HE TOOK A HOMETOWN DISCOUNT HERE, AND THE #OILERS GOT A PLAYER THEY NEEDED TO KEEP AT A VERY GOOD PRICE.

— JONATHAN WILLIS (@JONATHANWILLIS) APRIL 1, 2013

Tell us again about your insight into the player that is Ladislav Smid, Jonathan.