Let's take a look at all the messages:
- Start of game
- Hello loyal townsfolk! Beware the Eternals. Membership is not free.
- Hello Townsfolk! The gift of Eternal powers are a contrived deceit.
- The Eternals are close to defeat, The Guardians will prevail.
- One more day and the Guardian victory will be complete
- There is scum among the Guardians.
Pika can't remember everything, but aren't the eternal powers the ones that aren't working? ECF's powers didn't go through, even though Pika attempted to help him on night 2. From #4 Pika saw that the Eternals were close to defeat. If Puxlut doesn't join the Eternals, then Chu thinks the guardians may have won. Pika's not the best at deciphering these clues, but it's at least worth a look and/or discussion.