Quote:
Originally Posted by Rathji
Thought about this all day, and I have decided we need to give starseed s chance to prove what he is claiming. For that reason I am inclined to believe him.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by GGG
Breaking down the Starseed scenarios
If he is town and MOT and telling the truth, just before we lynch his mason buddy will come out and defend him. There is no way the mafia could afford to lose two members on one original claim. So if we pursue the vote on Starseed we know we either lynch scum or reveal 2 known townies who both validate themselves in the MOT thread.
|
The issue with these plans is (I believe Oling touched on it right after but these are the quotes I had added to multi quote scrolling through on my phone) that it would be really easy for another mafia member to come forward as starseed's 'mason partner'. I disagree with GGG in saying that the mafia wouldn't risk outing a second member. It seems to me it would be a great way to at least buy some time or, best case, have the town (proven to be possible by your theory) take them as known townies. When twilight comes, there is starseed proving he is the MOT, but for me and many others, not proving anything about being a townie.