Quote:
Originally Posted by GGG
Breaking down the Starseed scenarios
If he is town and MOT and telling the truth, just before we lynch his mason buddy will come out and defend him. There is no way the mafia could afford to lose two members on one original claim. So if we pursue the vote on Starseed we know we either lynch scum or reveal 2 known townies who both validate themselves in the MOT thread.
The nice thing about this is that going into Night 3 we will have 4 living fairly confirmed townies. Wood, ECF, Starseed, Mason2. If no one claims in a reasonable time we lynch him. Which means even with two possible kills we still keep two confirmed townies alive.
I think taking Starseed to near lynch makes a lot of sense at this point. The value of the mason is that you have an in game idea filter so you don't post all the paranoid crap so you look very credible. That aspect of the mason power is gone now for Starseed though still present for his partner. So as long as we are comfortable with outing his partner Starseed is probably the best target.
|
GGG the problem is, is that girlysports and puxlut have already faced accusations for their seemingly alignment of starseed. If stars seed reveals mafia they already the top of the list, especially girlysports for me. So coming in and saying one of them are his mason buddy will give them at least another day if the vote does change.
I don't doubt that starseed is working with someone in the MOT threads, just don't see a reason to assume they are town. At this point a starseed death would reveal more to the town than anything else. If he is town, we know we can trust the other MOT, we know he wasn't part of the guardian and eternal mess, we'll know if he actually believes there are two factions, and we'll do it without having to reveal another role. Of course that will likely spell the death of me tomorrow.
If he returns mafia, we can lynch girlysports or take a closer look at puxlut. I'll have no doubt you are town, and along with wood and east coast flame, plus our hidden cop, this will put the town in a great position.
I fear that a reveal by girlysports or puxlut and people hoping off of starrseed will just force a cop reveal.
Still suspicious of formulate though.