Quote:
Originally Posted by Oling_Roachinen
Delgar, ignoring the extra variables, there's 4 situations:
1. I'm mafia, you're town: In that case, for whatever reason, I am trying to put a target on your back but you should still be happy to answer the questions I have for you. You're town, you got nothing to hide. I'm the person you want to keep talking in hopes I slip up or am discovered to be scum.
2. I'm town, you're town: We are both suspicious of each other and that sucks. But we should be communicating and answering each others questions. I believe I have a very fair question with regards to how you decided to pick Bowser to vote. As far as I'm aware, and correct me if I'm wrong, you came to the conclusion it had to be a Nintendo creation so that ruled out Pac-man and Sonic. Explain or correct the logic for me. The worst case scenario is we keep voting each other and when one of us get revealed the other gets lynched for their persistent questioning.
3. I'm town, you're mafia: Here it makes a bit more sense to me why you wouldn't want to have to continue to discuss things as you might get caught in an inconsistency you can't explain.
4. I'm mafia, you're mafia: In that case we're planning this in our secret thread anyways.
I'm not ruling out two, but if you aren't going to address my questions (and vice versa) then we're both hurting the town.
I don't care that you voted Puxlut, I'm just concerned how you arrived at the conclusion because I don't follow it.
And I've been persistent on mrkajz44 as well but he attempted to answer my questions and if GP_Matt does reveal town I will probably have him on my town list.
|
OK you've baited me into this with a long post and so I have to respond. I've clipped a bit of it. Here's some logic for you, and frankly it leads to the conclusion you may actually be mafia.
-I know I'm not mafia. I can exclude 3 and 4.
-Are we both town? I suppose 2 is possible but I'm on you for me wanting to re-explain what I have explained in depth...it shows you didn't actually read my posts. Think CaptainCrunch's mistake.
-Your option 1, you're mafia I'm town, is entirely plausible... its you again setting up an invalid argument within the paragraph... I already answered as much as I can. To invalidate the option because of something not true, well, you just make yourself appear more mafia.
I'm sure I won't get support for this yet, but in the future, as cards flip, I think I will.
unvote
vote: Oling_Roachinen