My scum list:
1. GP_Matt: Has been purposefully vague and caught in a couple contradictions. I have thought he was scum since day 1 and I haven't changed my mine.
2. GGG - has been all over the place and has accused about 2/3rds of the posters for something - feel like he is throwing crap against the wall to try and get something stick. Has made some odd voting choices - I didn't follow his logic on a few votes. Has voted against the grain a few times - maybe trying to avoid looking like a pile on? Wants as much information out there as possible (wants people to vote often, explain their votes, wants people to make lists etc). Could be good strategy, but also could be scum trying to gain as much info on everyones thought patterns - use it to redirect or protect from night activites.
3. hmmmmmmmmmccccccammmmmmmmmmmmm - Admitted that they were laying low as a strategy. Only appears when called out and then has been really defensive when people accused him.
People I am on the fence about:
1. Girlsports - I was convinced she was scum for a while, but her posting over the weekend swayed me. I do think she is still playing way too defensive though.
2. Puxlut - I don't know if I buy the confused "aww schucks" attitude. Definitely not enough to go on for now though.
Town list:
1. Oling - has thrown a lot out there, but I think their logic has always made sense to me and hasn't slipped up on contradicted themselves.
2. Dissentowner - crusade against GP_Matt has made sense.
3. Timbo - Has asked a lot of questions and the questions seem to be mostly pro-town
|